If your dog treats every remote control, shoe, and table leg like a chew toy, you already know chewing is not optional for most dogs. It is normal behavior, and trying to stop it usually just moves the target to something you would rather keep intact.
So the useful question is what to hand them. Plenty of things sold as chew toys are hard enough to break a tooth or small enough to swallow, and either one can end in a vet visit. The short version is that a safe chew gives a little when you press it and is too big to disappear down the throat.
Why Dogs Need to Chew
Chewing is not just a puppy phase. Puppies chew to explore and to ease teething, and adult dogs keep at it because chewing is a normal exploratory behavior, especially in a dog that is bored or stressed and has nothing better to do. A dog without an acceptable outlet usually finds one anyway, and it is rarely the one you would have picked. That is why the standard advice for a dog left on its own is to leave appropriate toys or chews within reach instead of trying to stop the chewing.
What Makes a Chew Toy Safe
A safe chew toy has to survive a determined jaw without breaking into pieces small enough to swallow, and it should give slightly under pressure instead of meeting a tooth with a rigid surface. Size matters as much as material. A toy sized for a miniature poodle is a choking risk for a Great Dane, so pick one that is bigger than your dog’s snout and a little wider than the mouth.
How the toy is meant to be used matters too. A rope tug is built for supervised play, not for hours alone, because frayed strands get swallowed, and long, thin objects like string can do more damage in the gut than other swallowed material.
How Hard Is Too Hard?
Two quick checks tell you most of what you need to know. The first is the fingernail test. Press your thumbnail into the surface, and if you cannot leave a dent, the chew is too hard for your dog’s teeth.
The second is the kneecap test. If you would not want to be hit in the kneecap with it, do not hand it to your dog. Antlers, real bones, cow hooves, and hard nylon bones fail both tests. When a dog bears down on something that will not give, the usual result is a slab fracture of the carnassial tooth, where a flake shears off the outer face of the tooth. That tooth, the large upper premolar dogs use for shearing, gets its name from the Latin caro, meaning flesh.
Chews and Toys to Skip
A few popular options carry more risk than most owners realize. Real bones, cooked or raw, can break teeth, and swallowed pieces are among the things surgeons end up removing from dogs’ stomachs and intestines. Sticks belong on the same list for the same two reasons.
Tennis balls make poor daily chews, because the abrasive fuzz wears down enamel over time. Squeakers and stuffing become a problem the moment they can be pulled out and swallowed in one piece. And any toy already showing cracks, missing chunks, or exposed stuffing has stopped being a toy and become a hazard.
Introducing a New Chew Toy
Watch a new chew toy closely the first few times, even one that suits most dogs. Some dogs try to bite off chunks straight away or find an edge to shred, and that first session tells you whether this toy is a match for this dog before you leave them alone with it.
If you have more than one dog, give a new chew to one dog at a time instead of dropping several into a shared space. Some dogs guard a prized object from anyone who comes near it, and a fight over a new toy is easier to prevent than to break up.
Keep checking after that. A toy that was fine when new can develop a weak spot, a missing chunk, or a hairline crack over weeks of use. Retire it once it is visibly smaller than when you bought it, has a piece missing, or no longer flexes the way it did out of the box. A new toy costs far less than a dental repair or an emergency visit for a swallowed fragment.
Which Chew Toys Are Worth Buying?
Two toys come up again and again, and they are not equally safe. Both are for chewing, not for cleaning teeth. If cleaner teeth are the goal, that is a job for chews built around dental benefit and a toothbrush, and a dog that fights the brush may do better with a dissolving dental strip.
The KONG Classic is the one to start with for most dogs. It is a single piece of rubber that gives under bite pressure, so it passes the fingernail test. Stuffing it with food turns chewing into a longer, more mentally engaging activity instead of a five-minute demolition job.
The Benebone Wishbone is the popular pick for dogs that want something to gnaw, and its curved shape is easy to hold between the paws. It is also flavored nylon, it will not pass the fingernail test, and the maker’s own safety guide warns that aggressive chewing can chip or crack teeth. If you use one, supervise, keep it away from very aggressive chewers and older dogs with weak teeth, and replace it once a piece about the size of a sugar cube has worn away.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.
When a Chew Toy Means a Vet Call
Most chewing is harmless, but a few signs mean the toy goes in the bin and you call your vet.
- 01
Pawing at the mouth
Or drooling that will not stop.
- 02
Broken tooth or bleeding gums
A tooth that looks chipped or cracked, or gums you can see bleeding.
- 03
A missing chunk of toy
A piece is gone and you cannot find it anywhere.
- 04
Vomiting or refusing food
Either one after a chewing session.
None of these means panic, but each one deserves a same-day call to your vet instead of waiting to see. Vomiting, loss of appetite, and lethargy are the usual signs of an intestinal blockage, and a swallowed piece that lodges there usually has to come out surgically. That situation can turn dangerous quickly.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional veterinary care. Always consult a licensed veterinarian regarding your pet’s health and nutritional needs. As an Amazon Associate, Vet Explains earns from qualifying purchases.
Was the article helpful?